Eligibility

The Measure of Intellect: Qualifications for Candidacy

Every student has ideas worth exploring and a unique voice worth developing. THLJ provides a platform for young writers to question, investigate, reason, and express their ideas through thoughtful essays. More than a competition, it is an opportunity to grow as a thinker and writer.

Lower Division

Grades 6-8

 Suggested length: 1,500 words max

Middle school students from around the world may submit a writing piece based on one of the three Lower Division prompts.

Upper Division

Grades 9-12

Suggested length: 4,000 words max

High school students worldwide may submit essays responding to one of the three Upper Division prompts.

This Year's Essay Prompts

Discover the 2026 essay topics for the Lower and Upper Divisions.

Explore the 2026 essay topics for each division. Middle school students (Grades 6–8) will respond to one of the designated Lower Division prompts, while high school students (Grades 9–12) may choose one of the three Upper Division prompts. Review the prompts below to find the topic that matches your division.

Theme A

In the Age of AI, What Does It Truly Mean to Be Human? As artificial intelligence becomes increasingly intelligent, creative, and capable of understanding human emotions, what makes humans unique? Is it our ability to think, feel, love, make moral decisions, or something else? What qualities make us truly human?

Theme B

Is Following Someone Else’s Path Still a Meaningful Way to Live? We often learn and grow by imitating others. Sometimes following someone else’s footsteps can help us become better versions of ourselves. But does a meaningful life require us to create our own path, or can we find purpose and fulfillment by following the path someone else has already made?

Theme C

Should We Interpret Religion Through Our Own Beliefs, or Follow Its Teachings Exactly as They Are? Religion is often rooted in traditions, sacred texts, and teachings passed down through generations. However, every individual has different experiences, values, and ways of understanding the world. Should people be free to reinterpret religious teachings based on their personal beliefs, or is preserving the original meaning more important?

Theme A

“God Is Dead” – Friedrich NietzscheFriedrich Nietzsche famously declared, “God is dead.” He did not simply mean that God physically ceased to exist, but rather that traditional religious and moral foundations were losing their authority in modern society. What do you think Nietzsche meant by this statement? Does the decline of religious influence create greater freedom for individuals, or does it leave society without a shared moral foundation? Can human beings create their own meaning and values without relying on religion or traditional beliefs? Develop your own argument in response to Nietzsche’s claim.

Theme B

Morality Without an Audience – Socrates and the Nature of IntegritySocrates believed that living a virtuous life requires us to act morally regardless of whether anyone is watching. Consider the following question: If you could lie, cheat, or break a moral rule without ever being discovered or facing consequences, would it still be wrong to do so? Is morality determined by the consequences of our actions, the intentions behind them, or the kind of person we become through our choices? Argue whether doing the right thing has intrinsic value, even when no one else will ever know.

Theme C

Create Your Own Philosophical QuestionIdentify a question about human nature, morality, society, knowledge, freedom, identity, or existence that genuinely challenges the way people think. Your question should not have an obvious or universally accepted answer. Develop an original philosophical argument by presenting your position, examining alternative perspectives, and challenging your own assumptions. Rather than simply expressing an opinion, explore why your question matters and what it reveals about the human experience.

Two cycles, two chances to enter

A Dual Opportunity for Academic Distinction and Scholarly Pursuit

To ensure the utmost intellectual rigor, this competition offers a dual-cycle framework for submission. Young scholars must carefully examine the guidelines tailored to their division and strictly adhere to the critical milestones detailed below, establishing the foundation for their academic inquiry and defense.

Cycle
Registration Closes
Submission Due
Defense Day

Summer

Fall–Winter

April, 1

October, 1

May, 1

Nov, 1

The first week of June

The first week of December

Submission Guidelines

Your Ideas. Your Voice. Your Opportunity to Be Published.

Explore the submission guidelines for The Hues & Logic Journal (THLJ). Learn about essay requirements, formatting, originality, and the submission process before entering. Each submission is an opportunity to develop your ideas, strengthen your reasoning, and share your unique perspective through thoughtful writing.

Please review all guidelines carefully to ensure your essay meets the requirements for your division.

Lower Division (Grades 6-8)

  • Suggested length: 1,500 words Max.
  • Essays must directly address the designated prompt.
  • Submissions should present a clear central idea supported by relevant examples and logical reasoning.
  • Students are encouraged to demonstrate original thinking, thoughtful analysis, and clear writing.

Upper Division (Grades 9-12)

  • Suggested length: 4,000 words Max.
  • Essays must clearly address one of the three Senior Themes.
  • Submissions should demonstrate a well-developed thesis, logical argumentation, and effective use of evidence.
  • Research-based essays should include appropriate citations and a list of references.
  • Students are encouraged to present original insights and engage critically with complex ideas.

Lower Division (Grades 6-8)

  • Suggested length: 1,500 words Max.
  • Use only one single font family (e.g., Times or New Baskerville, but not both) throughout.  You may use any font styles (italic, superscript, etc.) within that single font family. If you need non-english characters or diacritics not available in your main font, you may use other fonts for the instance of a non-english word or diacritic.
  • The Hues & Logic Journal does not publish charts, photos, graphs or other graphics in essays.
  • Files must be in MS Word or RTF format only. We DO NOT accept Apple Pages, GoogleDocs, PDF, etc. You must convert them to MS Word or RTF before submitting.
  • The filename of your document should be your first and last name followed by an underscore and the first 3 words (ONLY) of your essay title.   Include spaces.  Use an underscore in place of a colon in the filename. DO NOT INCLUDE COMMAS or any other punctuation. Your first and last name should be the ones you used in filling out the form. Use the same name (first and last) that you used on your submission form.
    • CORRECT: Jeff Jones_The Founding Fathers.docx
  • Submit only one file.  

Upper Division (Grades 9-12)

  • Suggested length: 4,000 words Max.
  • Use only one single font family (e.g., Times or New Baskerville, but not both) throughout.  You may use any font styles (italic, superscript, etc.) within that single font family. If you need non-english characters or diacritics not available in your main font, you may use other fonts for the instance of a non-english word or diacritic.
  • The Hues & Logic Journal does not publish charts, photos, graphs or other graphics in essays.
  • Files must be in MS Word or RTF format only. We DO NOT accept Apple Pages, GoogleDocs, PDF, etc. You must convert them to MS Word or RTF before submitting.
  • The filename of your document should be your first and last name followed by an underscore and the first 3 words (ONLY) of your essay title.   Include spaces.  Use an underscore in place of a colon in the filename. DO NOT INCLUDE COMMAS or any other punctuation. Your first and last name should be the ones you used in filling out the form. Use the same name (first and last) that you used on your submission form.
    • CORRECT: Jeff Jones_The Founding Fathers.docx
  • Submit only one file.  

Originality

  • All essays must be the student’s original work.

  • Previously published essays or essays submitted to other competitions or journals are not eligible.

  • Plagiarism, unauthorized collaboration, and misrepresentation of authorship are strictly prohibited.

AI Use

  • Students must be the primary authors of their submissions.

  • AI-generated essays or substantial AI-generated writing are not accepted.

  • Students are responsible for the accuracy, originality, and authenticity of their work.

Submission Process

  • Submit your essay through the official THLJ submission form.

  • Provide accurate student information, including name, grade, school, and contact information.

  • Only one submission per student is permitted for each competition cycle.

  • Incomplete or late submissions may not be considered.

Evaluation Criteria

All submissions will be evaluated based on the following criteria:

  • Originality of Thought: Fresh perspectives and independent thinking.

  • Critical Thinking: Depth of analysis and thoughtful engagement with the topic.

  • Argumentation and Evidence: Clear reasoning supported by relevant evidence.

  • Organization and Clarity: Logical structure and effective communication.

  • Writing Quality: Grammar, vocabulary, style, and overall presentation.

Publication and Recognition

Selected essays may be recognized through awards and featured in The Hues & Logic Journal.

By submitting an essay, students grant THLJ permission to consider their work for publication. Authors retain ownership of their original work. Any publication will be subject to the required author and, where applicable, parent or guardian consent.

THLJ reserves the right to reject submissions that do not meet its eligibility, originality, or academic standards.

Parent or Guardian Consent

Students under the age of 18 must obtain parent or guardian consent where required for participation and publication. THLJ may request additional authorization before publishing selected student work.

button